Top 10 Questions to Ask Before Hiring a Criminal Defense Lawyer

1. What Is Your Experience With My Specific Type of Charge?

Criminal law is broad. An attorney who primarily handles DUI cases may not be the best choice for a federal white-collar prosecution, and vice versa. Ask the lawyer how many cases similar to yours they have handled in the past two to three years. Request specifics: How many went to trial? How many resulted in dismissals or reduced charges? An experienced criminal defense attorney will have no hesitation discussing their track record with your particular charge type.

You can also browse criminal defense attorneys on our directory to compare backgrounds before scheduling consultations.

2. What Is Your Trial Experience?

Many criminal cases are resolved through plea negotiations, but your attorney's willingness and ability to go to trial is what gives them leverage during those negotiations. A prosecutor who knows your lawyer has never tried a case will have far less incentive to offer a favorable deal. Ask how many jury trials the attorney has conducted, and what the outcomes were. An attorney who is genuinely prepared to take your case to trial will secure better results at every stage of the process.

3. How Do You Structure Your Fees?

Criminal defense attorneys typically charge in one of three ways: a flat fee for the entire case, an hourly rate, or a hybrid model. Understand exactly what is included. Does the flat fee cover a trial, or only proceedings through the preliminary hearing? Are there additional charges for expert witnesses, investigators, or filing fees? Ask for a written fee agreement and read it carefully before signing. Transparency about money at the outset prevents disputes and surprises later.

4. Who Will Actually Be Working on My Case?

In larger firms, the attorney you meet during the consultation may not be the one who appears in court or handles the day-to-day work on your file. Ask directly: Will you personally handle my case, or will it be assigned to an associate or junior attorney? If other team members will be involved, ask to meet them and understand their roles. There is nothing inherently wrong with a team approach, but you deserve to know who is making the strategic decisions.

5. What Is Your Communication Style and Availability?

One of the most common complaints clients have about their lawyers is poor communication. Establish expectations from the start. Ask how often you will receive updates and through what channels — phone, email, or a client portal. Find out how quickly you can expect a response when you reach out with a question. Some attorneys designate specific days for client calls, while others respond within 24 hours. The key is that their communication style aligns with your needs and expectations.

6. What Is Your Preliminary Strategy for My Case?

A good criminal defense lawyer should be able to outline a general strategic approach even during an initial consultation. While they may not have all the details yet, they should be able to identify potential defenses, likely procedural steps, and key issues that will affect the case. If an attorney is unable or unwilling to discuss even a preliminary strategy, that may indicate a lack of experience with your type of charge or a reluctance to commit to a plan of action.

For a deeper dive into evaluating legal representation, our guide on how to choose the right lawyer covers additional factors to consider.

7. Can You Provide References From Past Clients?

While confidentiality limits what former clients can share, many satisfied clients are willing to serve as references. An attorney who has consistently delivered strong results and positive client experiences should be able to connect you with at least one or two former clients who can speak to their professionalism, communication, and effectiveness. If a lawyer refuses outright or seems uncomfortable with the request, take note.

8. What Is a Realistic Timeline for My Case?

Criminal cases can resolve in weeks or drag on for more than a year, depending on the jurisdiction, the complexity of the charges, and court scheduling. Ask the attorney for a realistic estimate of how long your case is likely to take. Understanding the timeline helps you plan your life, manage stress, and set appropriate expectations. Be cautious of any attorney who guarantees a specific outcome or an unusually fast resolution — no ethical lawyer can promise results.

9. What Are the Potential Outcomes of My Case?

An honest attorney will discuss the full range of possible outcomes, from best case to worst case. Ask about the likelihood of dismissal, the possibility of reduced charges, potential sentencing ranges if convicted, and whether diversion programs or alternative sentencing options might be available. Understanding the spectrum of outcomes allows you to make informed decisions about plea offers and trial strategy. Be wary of any lawyer who only tells you what you want to hear.

10. What Happens If I Cannot Afford Your Full Fee?

Financial stress should not prevent you from getting quality legal representation. Ask whether the attorney offers payment plans, sliding scale fees, or any flexibility in their billing arrangements. Some criminal defense attorneys will work with clients to structure payments over the duration of the case. Additionally, if you qualify, you may be entitled to a public defender. A reputable attorney will be straightforward about your options rather than pressuring you into a financial commitment you cannot sustain.

Making Your Decision

After asking these ten questions, take time to reflect before making your choice. The right criminal defense attorney will demonstrate specific experience with your charge type, a proven willingness to go to trial, transparent fee structures, clear communication practices, and honest assessments of your case. Trust your instincts as well — you need to feel comfortable confiding in this person during what may be one of the most difficult chapters of your life.

If you are ready to start your search, browse criminal defense attorneys in our directory to find experienced lawyers in your area. Taking the time to ask the right questions now can make all the difference in the outcome of your case.

Find the Right Lawyer